|
July
22, 2004--
Just won an eBay auction for a rebuilt
Holley 2 barrel carburetor for the "bargain
basement" price of $50.07! The carb is a
2110 and according to my handy dandy
calculator and box of crayons, should flow
about 165 CFM. My only worry about this
carburetor is the width/ length of the carb
base. I was shooting for a single barrel
Holley or even Stromburg, but the ones I
could find were either VERY old and worn out
or VERY expensive (or both). I have two
extra stock carb sets (GL 1000 and GL 1100)
which should pay for the development costs
of my "new" intake... More to come! YEE HAA!
=)
Back to Top
I
have finally progressed to the point of
mock-up of the intake "plates" and mounting
of the Holley carburetor. If all goes well,
placement of the nylon adaptor plates and
carburetor mounting plate will come soon!
This
is the rear of the intake with plates
attached. Instead of having a carburetor
mounted at each point, a straight piece of
PVC pipe will run to the stock aluminum
"elbow" and into the head. You will notice
that the perch for the accelerator wheel and
choke are ground off. I may end up grinding
off the "foot" at the bottom of the picture
as well.
The
Holley 2110 is almost a perfect fit into the
stock air box opening. A thicker piece of
nylon will be cut and utilized as a mounting
plate between the carburetor and intake.Stay
tuned for more developments!
Back to Top
Second
Mock- Up
Over
a year since suffering a brain cramp and
coming up with this weird and wonky thought
about throwing out the metal and embracing
polyvinylchloride, the second mock-up is
made and ready for fitment!
Ain't
she pretty!!?? A mug only a mother could
love, huh? The original air box is the
silver hunk surrounded by the slabs of white
stuff. The slabs are 1/2" nylon "blocks"
(similar to what cutting boards are made
of). The intake runners shooting off to the
sides are simple 1& 1/4" PVC pieces cut
to 4 inch lengths. The blue goo is good ol'
RTV blue silicone sealant. The challenge to
making this thing, and keeping it running is
to turn an "everyday" (leaky) air filter
housing into an airtight assembly. Hence,
the tube of blue goo...
Side
shot giving a better view of the carburetor
flange. The stock air filter housing has two
bolt holes sunk in at opposing corners which
normally hold the air filter assembly
together. After cutting the dimensions of
the flange, a good friend, Big Ed (and one
HELLUVA Harley builder), drilled a hole into
each corner. He then countersunk two bolts
(the blue circular spots) into the stock
bolt holes and then double threaded two
flange bolts on opposite corners (bolts
sticking up). The carburetor came with a
very heavy, cast iron intake flange, making
fitment of the carb to the nylon flange
"do-able" with only two bolts.
Back to Top
FRANKENTAKE
LIVES!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What's
it cost to build the damn thing!?
Long
Term Test Update (added
1/27/2007)
Results
from first Shake Down run: High
Speedadded
6/11
Results
from second Shake Down run:
Low Speed/ Around Town
(added 6/12)
Long
Term Testing in Progress... 100 Miles
Down... No Problems! (added
6/14)
Lon
Term Testing Continues... 1,000 miles
Down... No Problems! (added
1/27)
Dateline June 7th,
2005...The intake (affectionately known as
"Frankentake") is in place and operational!
DAMN! She sounds good!!!!!
Finishing
touches included sealing the carburetor
flange into place with RTV blue silicone,
and squirting the whole she-bang with high
dollar (ninety-nine cent) flat black paint
straight from the rattle can! Ya' jus' can't
beat the look of flat black and polished
aluminum!
As
you can see, the assembly really doesn't
look all that bad painted flat black and
partially hidden from view. The carburetor
sits sideways on the intake, placing the
throttle and choke assemblies at the front
near the radiator and the idle adjustment
screws conveniently located the side of the
arrangement. The large black hose at the
left is the fuel line running from the stock
fuel pump up, up, up to the fuel inlet near
the top left side of the carb. I was
concerned about the pump pumping, but so far
it's doing a good job. The smaller black
hose at the bottom middle of the carb is the
hose running to the vacuum advance.
Better
shot of the fuel inlet. The carb sits very
close to the top frame rail. I was concerned
about it rubbing against the rail over time
so "fixed" the problem with my small sledge
hammer by "squishing" the frame rail over a
tad. =)
You
can see my handy work just behind the
regulator/ rectifier (I removed it before
wacking off on the frame rail) =)
Not
bad looking, huh? God, it sounds great!
Reminds me of the big block Impala I had as
a teenager! The throttle response is just
amazing! Franentake lives, but the SHAKEDOWN
has just begun...
Next
step: Grabbing my cell phone (just in case)
=) and burning the rubber of the thing to
break it in... Or just break it? Long term
concerns center around my ability to
completely seal the intake and keep it
sealed. It should be interesting to see how
the PVC and Nylon holds up to time,
temperature and fuel... More updates to
come!
Back
to Top
What's
it cost to build the damn thing!?
Updated 1/27/2007
So far, this
has been an extremely affordable
endeavor... Piece-by-piece costs are:
-
3 tubes of
RTV Blue Silicone (re-gooped
the intake after 1 year...added 1 tube
of RTV)-$12.00
-
36 inch
piece of 1 & 1/4"
PVC--------------------$2.35
-
Holley
Model 2110 Carburetor(with
shipping)--------$62.00
-
Rattle can
flat black
paint-------------------------- .99
-
Miscellaneous
bolts & such (scrounged
at home)-------free
-
Nylon
plates cut from scrap
(found behind food store)----free
-
Fuel line
(left over at auto
parts store)----------------------------free
-
Air
Breather Assembly (junk
Triumph part)---------------free
GRAND
TOTAL---------------------------------------->
$77.34
Back
to Top
Shake
Down Run #1
Dateline
June 11th: Spent
the morning making a throttle cable mount
and choke mount for the carb. Both came out
remarkably well using junk laying around the
house. I utilized the Holley's stock
accelerator assembly and ran the "pull"
cable to one end of it and a small spring to
the other to act as a "counter". Removed the
"push" cable from the throttle and threw it
in the pile of other goodies I don't need
anymore and began fabricating the choke
cable. Used a choke cable and assembly from
a junk Honda CX 500 (Similar to the choke
assembly found on a Goldwing). Fired up the
grinder and fabricated a mount which is
bolted to the lower frame rail in between
the right side intake runners. After making
sure choke and throttle operation were spot
on I fired up the bike and WOW! I never
thought adding a different carburetor set up
would have THAT much of an effect on a
motorcycle... To be fair, the old carbs were
pretty shot, but it was like riding a brand
new motorcycle. Top speed was somewhere at,
around, or over 100 mph (stock speedo gauge
only goes to 85 so that's an estimate) and I
hit 65 in second gear.
Some people who have
attempted a similar conversion using a
Volkswagen carb have complained about a
rough idle as the bike "loads up" if sitting
for too long. I calculated the CFM and the
Holley 2110 is a bit larger than the stock
carbs altogether (about 165-175 CFM) but
shouldn't load up all that quickly if I
added and subtracted right. I didn't give
the critter much chance to sit and idle
today =) but am planning on riding the bike
into town tomorrow morning (God willin' and
the creek don't rise). Played around with
the fuel/ air mixture screws to drop down
the idle a bit (that may be something to
work on as well). Stock air box (now
manifold) seems to be holding up well. I was
amazed after "flogging the dog" as hard as I
did that the intake runners and manifold/
carb combo were nice and cool at shut
down... The REST of the bike sure wasn't! =)
Shake Down Cruise
number 1 is "officially" in the books... Now
lets' see how she does in a more "civilized"
manner around town.... More to come soon.
Back
to Top
Shake
Down Run #2
(added June 12)
Sunday morning dawned
hot and humid with storm clouds on the
horizon and I debated on whether to tempt
fate once again and continue with my
shakedown of the new carb/ intake combo. I
burned a little sage to dispel the evil
spirits, said a few words to Wingolana,
Goddess of Goldwings, and swung a leg
over... The bike fired to life at the touch
of the button and I (literally) was able to
idle without choke after about 30 seconds.
The bike performed well around town. It DID
load up a couple of times at the longer
stoplights but the bike didn't quit and I
was able to "clean its throat" with a couple
blips of the throttle. I don't mind the bike
loading up a bit and may just leave the
fuel/ air mixture alone for now. Off idle
acceleration from stops is just amazing! I
was running a set of GL 1000 carbs on my
bike before this transition (no accelerator
pump on the older carb sets) and there is a
world of difference between the stock carbs
and the Holley. The most "niggly" concern I
have is a very high pitched whine from the
carb throat when I get on it a bit. All in
all, I am very pleased and more confident in
the carb. intake assembly after today...
Long term experimentation will determine if
this design holds up or becomes troublesome
over time. I'll keep you appraised at
regular intervals. Until then, I can
recommend this design as a viable
alternative for mounting a single carburetor
in place of the stock originals...
Choke
knob is peeking out under tank shell.
Long Term Test Update (addded 1/27/2007)
It's
been awhile since I updated this page with
the on-going results of my carb experiment.
Since the conversion, I have put just over
1,000 miles on the Goldwing. The bike is
still running like a champ. In fact, it is
running better now than it did when i first
completed the conversion. This is due, in
part, to a small intake leak which was
sealed this past spring which had developed
between one of the nylon plates and aluminum
airbox. As you may recall, I "mated" the
intake runners to the stock airbox through
the use of nylon plates held in place with
screws and lots of blue RTV. Over time, the
nylon has cracked in a few places where the
screws go through the nylon and secure the
the nylon to the aluminum body. The nylon
cracked allowing a small intake leak to
develop which cause rough idling to occur. I
re-tourqued the screws holding the nylon in
place and bought another tube of blue RTV
and gunked the whole she-bang up again.
Since the spring, the bike starts in an
instant, idles without choke in literally
seconds and SCREAMS down the road. I plan on
removing the manifold again this spring to
check for any additional cracking, but I
started the bike up this morning and she ran
just as well as she did when I parked her
for the winter. I'll tell you, this is one
conversion which I have been very pleased
with.
Long Term Test Update (addded 7/27/2009)
With
about 7,000 miles on the carb setup, I have
to say that I continue to be impressed with
its performance. The bike has actually
smoothed out a bit the more I have ridden
it. I recently bought a '82 GL 1100
Aspencade (stock engine with about a ton of
chrome goodies on it)... OH MY GOD,
what a SLUG compared to my rat! The
combination of the bags and extra "garbage"
on the bike coupled with stock carbeuration
definitely makes it a "tourer" and not a
"go-fast" critter. I LOVE ridin' FUBAR
around town and on Poker Runs. It sounds
grat and gets looks and questions all of the
time. The garbage wagon will stay stock. A
carb rebuild kit from Randakk's Cycle Shop
(not cheap but from what I hear, worth it)
should bring the garbage wagon closer to the
performance of FUBAR. I do not regret this
conversion at all! =)
Back
to Top
Long-term
Updates and Close-ups
of the Carburetor Assembly
Carburetor
close-ups
The
following pictures were taken
after I modified a junk Triumph
Air Breather Assembly to fit the
caburetor throat... I added the
"Triumph" points cover to the top
of the assembly because, while my
raggedy Goldwing will never be
confused with a Triumph, it IS a
triumph to actually see an idea
(crazy as it may be) come to
fruition. Folks, I have put all of
this information on to the site
not to brag or show off, but to
show that it CAN be done... And be
done by "Joe Schmoe"... I am NOT a
mechanic, metal fabricator or
anything like that, and I was able
to make this critter work, so YOU
should be able to do the same. If
you think you want to try
something similar, please feel
free to zap me your questions. I
am more than happy to help with
anything I can.
This
is "head on" view of the
carburetor as seen front-to-back.
The throttle and choke assembly
are located at the "front" of the
carb. As you can see, there is
nothing "special" about my work...
I believe in the power of zip
ties, Blue RTV and bailing wire.
=)
Running
a throttle "counter" spring to the
throttle assembly allowed me to
get rid of the "pull" cable to the
handlebar control. It gives good
feedback and feels almost the same
as the stock throttle at the
handlbars. The choke assembly is
run to the lower frame rail on the
bike. It's pretty convenient and
hardly noticeable, but I keep
wanting to reach up front to where
the stock choke was placed. =)
This
view is "back to front" as seen
from the saddle. The vacuum
advance and air/ fuel mixture
screws are located on the right
(fuel pump side) of the carb
making adjustments very easy. The
fuel inlet is at the very top of
the carb assembly... As I wrote
before, I was concerned about the
stock fuel pump's ability to pump
fuel so much farther and higher
than with the stock carb set, but
it has not been issue. The only
"modification" I made to the bike
frame is to hammer the top frame
rail over a bit to make room for
the inlet valve. Look just below
the "Air" tag and you may be able
to see the squashed frame rail. I
probably could have moved the
entire carb assembly over to the
right by making the intake runners
longer on the left side and
shorter on the right... As it is,
the assembly is hanging solid and
without any noticeable defects.
Back to Top
|
| Long-term
Updates
I'll try
to keep this area of the site
updated weekly until I am
convinced there will be no sudden
or catastrophic problems with this
arrangement.
Added:
6/14/05-- I have a total
of 100 miles on the assembly as of
today... Noticeable issues so far
are limited to an off-idle stumble
after I sit at a stoplight for
some time. The carb is loading up
a bit, and stumbles from time to
time at take off. So far, a quick
"blip" of the throttle has cleared
the problem without additional
issues. I added a home-made air
breather today and am hoping it
will help restrict air flow a
little bit, helping with the
loading up problem. I have
previously downloaded Holley's
service manual for this particular
carb (Holley 2110), and it has a
detailed section on adjusting the
fuel/ air mixture... This will be
my next task before taking the
bike back onto the road. I am
confident that I can get the
air/fuel mixture straightened out
soon. Even if the carb continues
to load up while idling, I am
very, very happy with the results
so far and plan to keep riding the
wheels off of the bike. More
coming soon!
Added:
6/17/05-- So far, so
good... Found a small intake leak
at the rear of the intake
manifold. Added more blue goo and
it looks good and back to running
fine... Having thoughts about
"sealing" the inner part of the
intake manifold with some sort of
impermeable coating. It looks like
left over gas is "pooling" in the
bottom of the manifold and
"eating" through the blue goo
making a leak... I'll have to nose
around for stuff. The fun
continues! =)
Added: 7/8/05-- The whole
reason I decided to try and build
an "alternative" intake was to see
if a common guy or gal could put
something together "on the cheap"
and have it work out... So far, my
experiment has worked out great!
To date I have racked up about 600
miles on the set up. It seems to
be holding together well, but
there are a few things I
would do differently if I did it
all over again:
1.
I bought a Holley 2110 carburetor
off of eBay cheap... The carb
itself is working just fine,
however, I must have made a
calculation error when trying to
figure out how big a carb
I could use. I thought the
2110 would work just fine, but it
tends to "load up" if sitting for
more than a few minutes, or at
longer stop lights. This isn't
much of a problem for me as I can
keep the bike running at a stop by
blipping the throttle, but it is
obvious that the carb should have
been smaller. My next modification
will be to order a smaller main
jet for the carb and see if I can
jet her down a bit. On the other
hand, I have NEVER had another
motorcycle launch as hard and run
so quick as the wing does now. One
of my other project bikes was a KZ
1000 P-4 (Police Special) that had
oodles of engine work done to it
when the cops had it to make it go
fast and I use to say
that it was THE fastest, and
quickest bike I ever rode... The
Goldwing, stripped down to nothing
and with the big carburetor, beats
the Kawai hands down. It's super
quick and I could not be more
pleased when she's up to speed.
2.
I have had one intake leak so
far... The leak was located at the
rear of the intake and I suspect
it was seepage through the
rubber gasket where the two halves
of the intake bolt together.
Originally, I used Blue RTV to
"seal" up the intake, but after a
few days, and when I noticed
the leak and removed the intake,
it was obvious that fuel was
puddling at the rear "floor" of
the intake and then deteriorating
the RTV Blue. The makers of RTV
say its good at gaskets but to
avoid continued and long term
exposure to fuel, so I took the
intake apart and used Indian Head
Shellac to seal up the halves and
THEN coated the external manifold
with a think layer of RTV. To
date, this mod has worked without
any problems. Fuel still puddles
(and probably will until I jet
down the carb) but it has not
seeped past the Indian Head
Shellac. THAT stuff, by the way is
worth its weight in gold, if ya'
ask me... I have re-used MANY head
gaskets over the years by glopping
good ol' Indian Head on the gasket
before re-installing it. (Good
stuff, Maynard!) =)
3.
I figure the PVC pipe will become
brittle over time and may start to
crack. Some friends have told me
to expect this and I will probably
scrounge some inch and a quarter
steel tubing from somewhere and
replace the PVC with it over the
winter. On the other hand, it
would be neat to see just how long
all of that plastic holds up. =)
Added:
7/27/09-- MAN! I
can't believe it's been four
years since the intake has
been on the bike! Aside from
some "niggly" problems (small
intake leaks), the intake and
carb have performed very well.
If you're mechanically
inclined, and dollar short
(like me), you might consider
building an intake similar to
mine. = )
Most Recent Goodies!
6/23/10
After seven years of
dependable service, the time has
come to overhaul my original design.
All things considered, the intake
has held up extremely well. The side
nylon plates have cracked at the
bolt mounts, but the PVC intake
runners are in remarkable condition.
The bike still ran well at speed but
it finally got to the point that it
would not idle properly. My guess is
that it was sucking too much air
through one or more cracks in the
nylon to maintain adle but once the
throttle was opened up, the problem
diminished. When I first sat out on
this intake journey, I was hoping
for a year or two of worry free
operation. Instead, I was able
to get 7 years and about 35,000
miles of operation from the setp.
Additionally, I could have removed
the intake, re-gooped the manifold
with RTV Blue and probably gone
another year or two with the
original set up.... Not bad for a
throw-together idea and an eBay
carburetor. =)
Back to Top
4/29/07
The saga
continues! Almost 3 years to the
day, I have removed the plastic
intake from my bike for a thorough
"look-see". Prior to this removal,
the intake was removed about once
per year for inspection and to
seal up any leaks which may have
occurred. I was afraid that the
PVC pipe would become brittle over
time, but it has held up extremely
well. The nylon "plates"
connecting the PVC tubes to the
aluminum intake housing has split
in a couple of places and I have
found a few intake leaks with this
last removal. I purchased some gas
tank sealant which seems to be
some sort of epoxy-in-a-stick and
will use that to fill any gaps
(Cost about 3 bux). It dries in 2
hours and cures in 12, so in a day
or so I will place a fresh coat of
RTV blue sealant over the repaired
areas and see how it holds up.
Back to Top
6/18/09
Well,
five years after I got ths
crazy ass idea, and 4 years
of actual operation, I am
happy to report that "Frankentake"
is aging well. Inspection
earler this year of the carb and
manifold showed no increase in the
stress cracks noted earlier.
The carb is holding up well
and I plan on disassembling it
next spring to give it an
internal inspection. The bike is
running GREAT! Here's a shaky
video of the bike running from
this morning. Sorry for the low
quality but I was trying to shoot
and operate the bike at the same
time.
Back to Top
|

|